Book: Dalail an-Nubuwwah by Bayhaqi
دلائل النبوة في خصائص التصور الإسلامي:
Chapter: Evidence of Prophethood in the Characteristics of Islamic Perception:
Volume: intro (Page:68)
English:
Evidences of Prophethood in the Unique Islamic Perception:
People only appreciate the necessity of the Prophetic message when they consider the state of the world before the advent of Islam – the lost humanity wandering in the darkness of prevalent misguidance, idolatrous concepts, and various forms of notions. Indeed, the prophets of the Children of Israel propagated pure monotheism, yet over time, they deviated, sinking into idolatry and regression, both after Moses and before him. The same goes for Christianity, where idolatrous practices and polytheism were introduced, influenced by hypocrites.On this, the American writer Draper, in his book "Religion and Science," states, "Idolatrous practices and polytheism infiltrated into Christianity influenced by hypocrites who held significant positions in the Roman state under the facade of Christianity. They were indifferent towards religious matters and were never dedicated to it. So was Constantine, who spent his life in tyranny and libertinism and barely committed to religious orders towards the end of his life in 337 AD."
"The Christian community, although it had attained such power that it...
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:69)
English:
Constantine the King and the Birth of a New Religion
Although Constantine the King attempted, he was unable to eradicate pagan beliefs completely, and he thus unsettled his principles. From this struggle arose a new religion where Christianity and paganism were equally apparent. Here, Islam differs from Christianity; it decisively eradicated its competitor, paganism, spreading its pure belief without any deception.
The emperor, who was a slave to the world and whose religious beliefs were insignificant, saw it as his personal interest and the interest of the two competing parties - Christian and Pagan - to unify and reconcile them. Even the established Christians did not deny this plan. They might have thought that the new religion would flourish if it was tasted and refined with old pagan beliefs, and that Christianity would eventually be purged from the filth and harm of paganism.
Disagreements in Christian Doctrine
The prominent Islamic researcher Professor Sayyid Qutb differs in his portrayal of Islam: A division occurred in Christian doctrine, some faction believed that Christ is purely human, and other groups professed the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit. These are just various manifestations through which God revealed Himself to people. According to them, God is composed of three entities: the Father, the Son, and the Holy Spirit (with the Son being Christ). God, being the Father, descended in the form of the Holy Spirit and embodied Mariam as a human being, hence when she gave birth to Jesus.
One faction argued that the Son is not eternal like the Father but is a creature created before the world, and therefore, He is less than the Father and subordinate to Him. Another faction denied the Holy Spirit as an entity.
The Council Decisions on Christian Doctrine
The Council of Nicaea in 325 AD and the Council of Constantinople in 381 established that the Son and Holy Spirit are equal to God in the divine unity. And stated that the Son was born from the eternities of the Father, and the Holy Spirit originated from the Father. The Council of Toledo in 589 then ruled that the Holy Spirit also proceeds from the Son, leading to a new division in the church.
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:70)
English:
East Church And West Church Continuously Diverged
As well as there exists a group that glorified Mary as they glorified Christ (peace be upon him). Dr. Alfred Butler mentions in his book “The Arab Conquest of Egypt, translated by professor Mohammed Fareed Abou Hadid”:
"Indeed, during the 5th and 6th Centuries, there was a continuous struggle between the Egyptians and the Romans, fueled by both ethnic and religious differences. The religious differences far outweighed the ethnic ones. At that time resentment was ripe between the Melkites and the Monophysites. The former group, as suggested by its name, was a faction that supported the Emperor and the church, believing in the orthodox dogma of Christ's dual nature. On the other hand, the Monophysite Copts of Egypt strongly detested and abhorred this dogma, fiercely challenging it with a fervor hard for us to imagine or understand in a people led by reason and believers in the gospel”.
The Constant Struggle And Attempt for Reconciliation
Sir T. W. Arnold mentioned in his book “Call to Islam” about this dispute, and Heraclius' attempt to resolve it through a middle ground approach:
"Indeed, a hundred years before the Islamic conquest, Justinian succeeded in giving the Roman Empire an appearance of unity, but it quickly crumbled after his death, and there arose a desperate need for a shared national sentiment to bridge the provinces and the capital. Heraclius made efforts to reattach Syria to the central government, but his methods, unfortunately, led to further division instead of resolving it. There was nothing to stand in for national sentiment except religious emotions. So, by interpreting the dogma in a way to soothe souls, he sought to tackle divisive issues."
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:71)
English:
Resolving Sectarian Disputes
Among the rival sects, a demand had arisen to unify those who have left the religion and the Orthodox Church, including their relationship with the central government.
Chalcedon Council Declaration
The Chalcedon Council proclaimed in 451 A.D., "Christ must be recognized as embodied in two natures, with no mixture, alteration, division, or separation between them. Their difference cannot be obliterated due to their union. Rather, each nature should maintain its characteristics, uniting in one person and one body, not as fragmented or separated into two persons, but united in one person: the single Son and God, and Word."
Rejection by the Jacobites
The Jacobites rejected this council, recognizing in Christ only a single nature. They said, "He is composite of hypostases, possessing all divine and human qualities. However, the matter joined by these qualities was not dual, but became a compound unity of hypostases."
Centuries Long Debate
A heated debate had raged for nearly two centuries between the Orthodox and the Jacobites, who particularly flourished in Egypt, the Levant and lands outside the Byzantine Empire. In this period, Heraclius strove for internal reform by advocating Monotheletism – the doctrine that Christ has a single will.
Monotheletist Doctrine
While this doctrine acknowledged the existence of two natures, it insisted on the unity of the divine person in Christ's human life. It denied the existence of two types of life in one person. The single Christ, the Son of God, achieved both the human and divine sides with one divine-human power. This meant that there was only one will in the incarnate Word.
Heraclius' Fate
However, Heraclius met the same fate as many others who had hoped to establish the pillars of peace. The dispute flamed up once again more fiercely than ever...
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:72)
English:
Deviation in Beliefs
Not only did the animosity persist, but also Heraclius himself was accused of impiety. He managed to invoke the wrath of both sects simultaneously! Indications of such deviations are found in the Holy Quran which admonishes the People of the Book and presents a decisive correction of them.
True Christian Belief
The Quran explains the true concept of the Christian faith as it was revealed by God, before any distortions or interpretations:
"Those who say, 'God is the Messiah, son of Mary,' have committed disbelief. The Messiah said, 'O Children of Israel, worship God, my Lord and your Lord.' Indeed, he who associates others with God - God has forbidden him Paradise, and his refuge is the Fire. There are no helpers for the evildoers."
"Those who believe that God is a third of a three have committed disbelief. There is no god except one God. If they do not desist from what they say, a painful punishment will afflict those among them who disbelieve. Will they not repent to God and seek His forgiveness? For God is Forgiving, Merciful."
"The Messiah, son of Mary, was nothing more than a messenger; many were the messengers that passed away before him. His mother was a woman of truth. They both had to eat their [daily] food. See how We make the Signs clear to them; yet see how they are deluded away from the truth! Say, "Do you worship beside God that which holds for you neither harm nor benefit? And yet it is God who is the Hearer, the Knower. Say, O People of the Book, do not exceed limits in your religion beyond the truth and do not follow the capricious desires of people who strayed in times gone by, who misled many, and strayed from the straight path."
Jewish and Christian Claims
The Jews say, "Ezra is the son of God," and the Christians say, "The Messiah is the son of God." That is their claim which they imitate from those who disbelieved before. May God destroy them; how are they deluded?
Jesus's Statement
And when God said, "O Jesus, son of Mary, did you say to the people, 'Take me and my mother as gods besides God?' " He said, "Exalted are You! It was not for me to say that to which I have no right. If I had said it, You would have known it. You know what is within me, and I do not know what is within Yourself. Indeed, You are the Knower of the unseen. I only told them what You commanded me to do, to worship God, my Lord and your Lord. And I was a witness over them while I dwelt among them. When You took me up, You were the Watcher over them, because You witness everything."
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:73)
English:
Perversions in Faith: A Historical Interpretation
'Punish them, for they are Thy servants or forgive them, for You are the Mighty, the Wise...' (Al-Ma'idah:116-118). So, we can see how much deviation infiltrated Christianity due to these historical circumstances, turning into those pagan mythological conceptions on which disputes and massacres revolved for centuries!
The Arabian Peninsula, where the Quran was revealed, was packed with a plethora of beliefs and perceptions. Among them were the teachings received from the Persians, as well as that which leaked into it from Judaism and Christianity in their deviated forms... added to its own inherent paganism which had regressed from the monotheistic creed of Abraham that the Arabs had inherited correctly but then distorted.
The Quran refers to this entire messy situation quite clearly. They claimed that the angels were the daughters of God - despite their own dislike for daughters! Then they worshiped angels - or their idol representations - believing that they have unrejected intercession with God, and that they can go closer to him by means of them:
'They assign unto Him a portion of His slaves... Lo! man is verily a disbeliever manifest. Or chooseth He daughters of all that He hath created, and honoureth He you with sons? And if one of them is given the good news of that which he likened to the Most Gracious, his face remains dark and he is suffocating. Who is raised among the adornments, and is in discord not clear? And they made the Angels who are servants to the Most Gracious females. Did they witness their creation? Their testimony will be recorded and they will be questioned. And they said if the Most Gracious willed it, we would not have worshipped them, they have no knowledge of that - they are just guessing...' (Al-Zukhruf: 15-20)
Only to God is the pure religion, and those who take guardians beside Him [say], 'We only worship them so that they may bring us nearer to Allah.' Indeed, Allah will judge between them in what they differ. Surely, Allah...
"Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:74)
English:
Divine Sovereignty and Misguided Worship
God guides whom He wills, and yet there are those who claim lies and reject Him. If God had willed to take a son, He could have chosen whatsoever He pleased from His creation. Praised is He. He is Allah, the One, the Irresistible. [Az-Zumar: 3, 4]
False Intercession and Ignorance
They worship other than Allah that which neither harms them nor benefits them, and they say, 'These are our intercessors with Allah.' Say: 'Do you inform Allah of something He does not know in the heavens or on the earth?' Exalted is He and high above what they associate with Him. [Yunus: 18]
They also made false claims of connection between God - may He be exalted - and jinns, assuming that God has a consort who bore Him angels and that they too worshiped the jinns. Al-Kalbi wrote in his book Al-Asnam (Idols): 'The sons of Milih from Khaza'ah worshiped jinns.'
Myths Debunked by the Qur'an
The Holy Qur'an dispelled these myths: 'So ask them, 'For your Lord, do you have daughters while for them, sons? Or have We created the angels as females, while they were witnesses? Surely, from their own invention, they say: 'Allah has offspring,' and they are truly liars. Have He preferred daughters over sons? What is the matter with you? How do you make your judgment? Then will you not be reminded? Or do you have a clear authority? Then bring your book, if you are truthful. They have made between Him and the jinn a lineage, and the jinn have already known that they [who made such claims] will be brought to [punishment]. Exalted is Allah above what they describe. [As-Saffat: 149-159]
'And the day when He will gather them all and then say to the angels: 'Was it you these [people] used to worship?' They will say: ‘Glory be to You! Our allegiance is only to You - not them. They used to worship the jinn; most of them were believers in them.' [Saba': 40,41]
Idol Worship
Among these people, idol worship was prevalent. They regarded idols either as representations of angels, as embodiments of their ancestors, or as deities in their own right. The Kaaba, which was built for the worship of the One True God, was full of idols; it contained three hundred and sixty idols, besides major idols scattered around. Some of these are mentioned by name in the Qur'an, like Al-Lat and Al-'Uzza.
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:75)
English:
The Idols of Pre-Islamic Arabs and Their Worship
The infamous idol Hubal, called upon by Abu Sufyan during the Battle of Uhud – "Exalt is Hubal!" – was among the many idols revered by the pre-Islamic Arabs. Yet, significant evidence indicates that Allat, Al-'Uzza, and Manat were embodied as statues representing angels, as cited in Surah An-Najm of the Quran:
"So have you considered al-Lat and al-'Uzza? And Manat, the third - the other one? Is the male for you and for Him the female? That, then, is an unjust division. They are not but [mere] names you have named them - you and your forefathers - for which Allah has sent down no authority. They follow not except assumption and what [their] souls desire, and there has already come to them from their Lord guidance. Or is there for man whatever he wishes? So to Allah belongs the Hereafter and the first [life]. And how many angels there are in the heavens whose intercession will not avail at all except [only] after Allah has permitted [it] to whom He wills and approves. Indeed, those who do not believe in the Hereafter name the angels female names. And they have thereof no knowledge; they follow not except assumption, and indeed, assumption avails not against the truth at all..." {An-Najm: 19-28}
Idol worship degenerated to such an extent that they began venerating stones! Al-Bukhari narrated from Abu Raja' al-'Utaridi, who said: "We used to worship stones, and if we found a stone that was better than the one we had, we would discard it and take the other! If we couldn't find a stone, we would gather some earth, then bring a sheep and milk it over it, then circumambulate around it."
Worship of Heavenly Bodies
Also, Al-Kalbi wrote in his book "Idols": "When a man travelled and stopped at a place, he would take four stones. He would choose the most appealing one as his god and use the remaining three as cooking stones. When he was about to leave, he would abandon them."
The Arabs had also developed a knowledge of celestial bodies and their worship, much like the Persians. Sa'id mentioned that the Hamir tribe worshipped the sun, the Kinanah tribe the moon, the Tamim tribe Al-Dabaran, the Lakhm and Judham tribes Jupiter, the Tai tribe Canopus, Qais worshipped Sirius, and the Asad tribe worshipped Mercury.
There are references to such forms of worship also in Surat Fussilat:
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:76)
English:
The Divine Creation and False Worship
"Do not bow down to the sun nor to the moon; rather, bow down to Allah who created them, if Him you truly worship... [Fussilat: 37]
He is also mentioned in the Surat an-Najm: "That He is the Lord of Sirius (the Mighty Star)…[Najm: 49]"
Creation of the Celestial Bodies
References to the creation of stars and planets and Allah's Lordship over them, like the rest of his creations, are plentiful. The sole aim is to negate the divinity of the heavenly bodies and their worship... However, the beliefs of polytheism had deeply infiltrated their lives leading to corrupt rituals referred to in the Holy Quran in numerous instances.
Agricultural and Animal Offerings
This included designating certain fruits and animal produce specifically for these so-called deities, with no share for Allah - The Exalted - Sometimes, they would prohibit these for themselves, or only allow them for males, not females. They would prevent certain cattle from being ridden or slaughtered. Often, they offered their children as sacrifices to these deities in the form of vows. This is illustrated in the tale of 'Abd al-Muttalib vowing to sacrifice his tenth son, if given ten sons for his protection. The tenth son was 'Abdullah who was later ransomed with a hundred camels! All of these rituals were presided over by priests and soothsayers!
Quranic Reflections
Reflecting upon this, the Holy Quran states: "And they attribute to Allah - out of what He created of [agricultural] crops and livestock - a portion, saying, "This is for Allah," by their claim, "And this is for our associate gods." What was meant for their associate gods does not reach Allah, and what was meant for Allah, does reach their associate gods! Evil is their judgement! Likewise, to many of the polytheists their partners have made [to seem] pleasing the killing of their children in order to do away with them and to confuse them in their religion...and they also said, "These animals and crops are forbidden." No one may consume them except those we permit - by their claim - cattle whose backs are forbidden, animals over which they do not mention Allah's name..."
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:77)
English:
Translation:
Their stating, 'What is in the bellies of such and such cattle is reserved exclusively for our males and forbidden to our wives.' * But if it is stillborn, they share in it.* He will punish them for their attributions. Indeed, He is Wise, Knowing.* They have lost, those who in their ignorance have foolishly slain their children and have forbidden what Allah has provided for them, inventing lies against Allah.* They have gone astray and were not guided.[Qur'an 6:136-140]
Pure Monotheism - A Strange Concept:
The idea of pure monotheism was extremely strange to them, just like the idea of resurrection. This was despite their acknowledgment of the existence of Allah - Glory be to Him - and that He is the Creator of the heavens and the earth and what is between them. However, they did not want to admit to the implications of this monotheism, which is that Allah alone is the ruler in their lives and affairs, and that He alone is the source of what is lawful and unlawful, and that it is to Him alone that they should turn for all their matters in this world and the Hereafter. And that they should refer to His law and His method alone in all things .. A matter that cannot be religion or faith without Him.
Quranic Evidence:
The evidence for this is what the Noble Quran narrates about their vehement opposition to these two truths: 'And they marvel that there has come to them a warner from among themselves. And the disbelievers say, "This is a magician, a liar. Has he made the gods into only one Allah? This is indeed a strange thing." And the leaders among them go about saying: "Go, and remain constant to your gods. This is a thing designed. We have not heard of this in the later faith. This is nothing but a fabrication...[Quran 38:4-7]
And those disbelievers say, 'Shall we point out to you a man who will inform you that when you have utterly torn yourselves to pieces, you shall be a new creation? Has he forged a lie against Allah, or is he mad?' Rather those who do not believe in the Hereafter will be in torment and astray...[Quran 34:7,8].
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:78)
English:
The Prevailing Conceptions in the Arabian Peninsula
This is the prevalent image of the conceptions in the Arabian Peninsula. We add this to the rubble of the remnants of deviated celestial beliefs, which dominated both the East and the West. On the advent of Islam, they congregate into a complete picture of that heavy rubble, which weighed on the conscience of humanity everywhere, from which their systems, situations, customs, and morals emerged.
The Guidance of Islam
Islam's major attention was directed towards liberating belief matters, defining the correct image upon which the human conscience settles in the reality of divinity, its relationship with creation, and the creations' relationship with it. Hence, their systems, situations, social, economic and political relations, and their manners and morals also settle on it. These things can all be settled only when the reality of divinity is settled and its characteristics and specializations become clear.
Islam's Special Attention
Islam paid special attention to clarifying the nature of divine characteristics and attributes related to creation, will, dominance, and management. It then focused on the actual link between God and humans. Most of the rubble was in that disarray in which beliefs and philosophies were entangled, matters that have a serious impact on the human conscience and life as a whole.
The Arrival of Islam
Islam arrived, and this deserves attention and contemplation, as a correction for all types of confusion that deviated religions and philosophies lost in darkness had fallen into. It is a response to all the deviations and errors committed by those religions and philosophies, whether before the advent of Islam or after it.
The Wonder of Islam's Emergence
This amazing phenomenon punctuates Islam's origins. The origin that encompasses all that preoccupies and intrigues the mind of mankind and then tackles it by collating and refining!
Arabic:
Volume: intro (Page:79)
English:
The Endeavors of Islam
In considering the protracted efforts made by Islam to pronounce the final word on God's self— The Exalted—his attributes, his relationship with creation, and their relationship with him, the sheer breadth of these efforts is embodied in the many verses of the Meccan Qur'an in particular, and in the Qur'an in general.
Humanity's Struggle with Divinity
Those who review these sustained efforts without contemplating the weighty rubble of prevalent confusion, a broad wandering into which all of humanity stumbled and continues to stumble whenever they deviate from God's path or turn away from it, to follow different paths and diverge from His straight, singular path, may not fully comprehend the depth of need for such assertive, iterative elucidations in the Qur'an, and for such meticulousness that traces all the ramifications of consciousness and life.
The Necessity of Efforts and Role of Faith
Reviewing that weighty rubble reveals the essentiality of these efforts, and the magnitude of the role this ideology was meant to play in emancipating human conscience and liberating it, in freeing human thought and unleashing it, and in liberating life itself. Life is based on the perceived belief, whatever it may be. Only then does one realize the value of this liberation in establishing life on a sound, upright path, by which the affairs of human life are rectified, and saved from corruption, confusion, injustice or degradation...
Understanding the Value of Islam
We can also understand the value of Omar's (may God be pleased with him) statement: "Islam unravels knot by knot for the one who was raised in Islam but does not know ignorance"... For the one who knows ignorance is the one who appreciates the value of Islam, knowing how to cherish God's mercy embodied in it, and Allah's blessing realized through it.
The Beauty and Perfection of Belief
The beauty of this creed, its perfection and harmony, the simplicity of the great truth it represents, all of this is not fully revealed to the heart and mind except when examining that rubble.
Arabic:
Chapters
- 1 . -
المقدمة - 2 . The First Volume
المجلد الأول - 3 . Introduction to the Evidences of Prophecy
[المدخل إلى دلائل النبوة] - 4 . Scholars' Opinions on Imam Al-Bayhaqi
أقوال العلماء في الإمام البيهقي - 5 . Scholars' Opinions on "Evidence of Prophethood"
أقوال العلماء في"دلائل النبوة" - 6 . The Introduction
التقدمة - 7 . Methods in Proving Prophecy
طرق في إثبات النبوة - 8 . 1 - Al-Ghazali's Method of Proving Prophecy:
١ - طريقة الغزالي في اثبات النبوة: - 9 . 2 - Ibn Khaldun's Method of Proving Prophethood:
٢ - طريقة ابن خلدون في إثبات النبوة: - 10 . 3 - Proofs of Prophecy in Khadijah's Conversion to Islam - May Allah be pleased with her:
٣ - دلائل النبوة في إسلام خديجة - رضي الله عنها -: - 11 . 4 - Evidence of Prophecy in the Islam of Abu Bakr the Truthful - May Allah be pleased with him -
٤ - دلائل النبوة في إسلام أبي بكر الصديق - رضي الله عنه - - 12 . "Evidences of Prophecy in the Islam of Abu Dharr al-Ghifari - May Allah be pleased with him -"
دلائل النبوة في إسلام أبي ذر الغفاري - رضي الله عنه - - 13 . "Evidences of Prophethood in the Islam of Talha bin Ubaidullah, may Allah be pleased with him"
دلائل النبوة في إسلام طلحة بن عبيد الله رضي الله عنه - 14 . "Evidences of Prophecy in the Conversion of Negus (the Abyssinian King) to Islam."
دلائل النبوة في إسلام النجاشي الأصحم. - 15 . Evidence of Prophethood in Zaid bin Sa'nah's Conversion to Islam:
دلائل النبوة في إسلام زيد بن سعنة: - 16 . "Evidences of Prophecy in the Conversion of the Doctor Damad to Islam."
دلائل النبوة في إسلام الطبيب ضماد: - 17 . Evidence of Prophecy in the Islam of the Clergy: Abdullah bin Salam:
دلائل النبوة في إسلام الحبر: عبد الله بن سلام: - 18 . Salman the Persian is searching for the truth:
سلمان الفارسي يبحث عن الحقيقة: - 19 . "Evidences of prophecy in the nobility of his life, peace be upon him, and his struggle:"
دلائل النبوة في سمو حياته صلى الله عليه وسلم وجهاده: - 20 . The Prophet, peace be upon him, in Ta'if:
الرسول صلى الله عليه وسلم في الطائف: - 21 . Evidence of Prophethood in the Characteristics of Islamic Perception:
دلائل النبوة في خصائص التصور الإسلامي: - 22 . Monotheism is the miracle of Islam.
التوحيد معجزة الإسلام: - 23 . Al-Bayhaqi's condition in his book and the distinct features of his compilation:
شرط البيهقي في كتابه وخصائص مصنفه: - 24 . The classifications in the Proofs of Prophethood and the methodology of the classifier:
المصنفات في دلائل النبوة ومنهج المصنف: - 25 . The Life of Al-Bayhaqi and His Scholarly Status:
حياة البيهقي ومكانته العلمية: - 26 . Scholars of Al-Bayhaqi:
شيوخ البيهقي: - 27 . The students of Al-Bayhaqi:
تلاميذ البيهقي: - 28 . His works:
مصنفاته: - 29 . The scholars' testimony of his virtue and knowledge:
شهادة العلماء بفضله وعلمه: - 30 . His piety and asceticism:
ورعه وزهده: - 31 . His poetry:
أشعاره: - 32 . His death:
وفاته: - 33 . His elegy:
رثاؤه: - 34 . Description of the approved versions used in publishing the evidences
وصف النسخ المعتمدة في نشر الدلائل - 35 . 2 - The second original version (A)
٢ - النسخة الأم الثانية (أ) - 36 . Copernican version: denoted as (k) :
نسخة كوبريللي: ورمزها (ك) : - 37 . Version (K) Headphones:
سماعات النسخة (ك) : - 38 . Egyptian Library Version (212) the conversation marked with the character (S)
نسخة دار الكتب المصرية (٢١٢) حديث المرموز لها بالحرف (ص) - 39 . The version of Al-Haythami denoted by the letter (H)
نسخة الهيثمي المرموز لها بالحرف (هـ) - 40 . Headphones of version (H)
سماعات النسخة (هـ) - 41 . Version (215), a recent publication from the Egyptian Book House, symbolized by the letter (F).
النسخة (٢١٥) حديث دار الكتب المصرية، المرموز لها بالحرف (ف) . - 42 . The version (M) in Al-Mahmoudia Library, in the Public Library of Al-Madina Al-Munawara (9) Prophetic Biography:
النسخة (م) بالمكتبة المحمودية بمكتبة المدينة المنورة العامة (٩) سيرة نبوية: - 43 . Description of the two versions (B) and (D):
وصف النسختين (ب) و (د) : - 44 . The newspaper of sources and references that were attributed to its page numbers and its parts, and the date of its editions during the verification of the book "Evidence of Prophethood".
جريدة المصادر والمراجع التي جرى العزو إلى أرقام صفحاتها وإلى أجزائها، وتاريخ طبعاتها أثناء تحقيق كتاب دلائل النبوة